Each year a small group of finalists is isolated for the grand prize round of judging. This is known as the "short list," which is announced publicly in the summer of each award year.
 
2013
Winner
Day 1. I stand lost amidst the green vegetables contemplating the meal I will make the next day. There will be ten of us to celebrate my brother’s birthday and I want to make something that everyone will enjoy. I find it difficult to focus my attention, tired from performing too many mundane tasks, but finally decide on pasta shells filled with ricotta cheese, Swiss chard and wild mushrooms, though I should have made the sauce yesterday.
Editor's Choice Award
2012
Winner
The man in the apartment below sports black, thinning hair, smokes endless Marlboros and has perhaps the smallest penis I’ve ever seen. Other than my husband Simon’s, I’ve not seen many, so I may be an inadequate judge. The hair above it is wilder than that which tries to grow on his shiny head and thicker than the spikes that sprout aggressively from his chin. He seems not to care about the waywardness or reluctance of his hair; I, however, will never forget.
Editor's Choice Award
2011
Winner
Lee and Red didn’t have anything better to do so they decided to go to a bar and get into a fight. Lee put on his favorite shirt—a light blue button-up with cowboy pockets. His girlfriend, Evelyn, had gotten it for him before she moved to Montana and stopped being his girlfriend. He called her and asked her what the hell’s in Montana, anyway, and she said, “Not you.”
Red came out of his bedroom wearing his fighting jeans, the ones with the holes in the knees. He checked himself in the mirror by the front door, took out a comb he kept in his pocket and went over his hair once, then he said, “I’m ready.”
Editor's Choice Award
back to top
2009-10
Winner
It was a country of bamboo jungles, swamps, mountains, and people wearing pajamas and conical hats; it was a land that grew graves marked by mounds the forest would soon shroud with silence. Winters were bone-shattering cold; summers brought sweltering heat that was a vampire sucking breath out of men’s lungs.
For Gunnery Sergeant Parker and First Lieutenant Jennings, Nam was a country viewed from their bellies when they went searching on their nightly patrol. Wearing jungle camouflage and stripes of black makeup to darken their faces, they inched silently through the jungle’s tangle, carrying rifles, spotter’s scopes, hand-loaded ammunition, honed knives, canteens, rations, death.
Editor's Choice Award
back to top
2008
Winner
I’m still alone because I can’t sleep with a woman. I mean I can’t share a bed and allow myself to fall asleep. Most of them end up thinking I’m some macho hard hat who just wants to have sex, and split, and I would rather they think that than know the truth.
When the dreams began I can’t say for sure. I was already living alone again, I know that.
I never fall off anything. It’s not like I’m up on the iron, crossing a beam, and lose my footing. There’s never something solid under my Red Wings that is suddenly gone. I’m already falling. I see nothing—no floors of an office building whipping past, no street rushing up to meet me. Wind burns my cheeks, the palms of my hands, tugs at my hair. I feel an intense wrenching in my stomach and head, as if my outside body is plunging faster than my organs. I have no clear thoughts of death, no fear of what I’ll hit when I land. There is no landing—ever—just blind, bottomless dropping, my body knowing somehow that there is nowhere to land.
Editor's Choice Award
Publisher's Choice Award
back to top
2007
Winner
Hieronymus Bosch dabs paintbrush to palette and confers with the small, round convex mirror floating alone in an ocean of bonewhite wall on the far side of his studio. Sharpness of eye, thinness of lip, satirical rage, he thinks: His whole family of attributes, God willing, will be out of this mess soon enough. Rotating back to his work at hand, he touches color flecks to the insectile legs rooted in the dwarf’s shoulder. Appraises.
Travel is sport for those who lack imagination. Bosch is sure of it. Take, by way of illustration, that huge, hideous Groot. That huge, hideous Groot does not possess a nose. He possesses a greasy, vein-webbed tumor partitioning two purple puckered assholes. A homuncular likeness of him hunches in the dark sky above the rendered Bosch’s raised left hand. Groot appears piggish as a gluttonous priest, ears donkey-large with gossip. The heavens churn with hell smoke. Below, the hilly countryside blazes with the firewind of belief. Yet, despite his mass, the emissary from the Brotherhood of Our Lady cannot stop moving. 'S-Hertogenbosch to Tilburg, Tilburg to Eindhoven, Eindhoven to Brussels, and back again, busying himself with business. What his sort does not know, cannot fathom, is that movement is nothing more than a forgetting, foreign landscapes forms of amnesia, journeying a process of unstudying. One must learn to stay put in order to see. Become a place. A precise address. Lot’s wife, that salty pillar. ...
Editor's Choice Award
Publisher's Choice Award
back to top
2006
I awoke out of senseless sleep--pinprick light spreading from a center of darkness like a rebooting computer monitor. Objects slowly stepped out of shade and sharpened, and I had the sensation of motion, of being lifted somewhere I didn't want to go. My fingers clawed for something taut, trying to anchor.
Born again. Reverse flushed up a mystery tunnel toward illumination and a not quite heavenly aura. I would have preferred unfolding into a brightly lit room while welcomed with happy urgency. I would have liked kindly beings to coo over me as I took in impressions not connected to preceding impresssions. I would have hoped to come off the long trip through the ether with no luggage other than an umbilical cord. ...
Runner Up
back to top
2005
If I had known that Lorraine was richer than a double fudge brownie, I never would have fucked her. You don't sleep with rich girls until you marry them, or at least not until they've promised to marry you. It's too risky. Sex brings so many complications to everything, especially when you run the risk that her Catholic father will walk in on the two of you, which is exactly what happened.
Where I come from, a seventeen-year-old virgin is harder to find than a graffiti-free street. The fact that Lorraine was twenty-four and lived alone gave me no fear of a parental intervention. We weren't teenagers, for chrissakes. But there we were, on her floral couch. (Her furniture was nice enough, definitely no IKEA futons, but it didn't scream, "I'm loaded-don't fuck me.") And we were right in the height of things--God, I was so close--when the door suddenly opened. There is little in the world more disturbing than a large bald man bursting into a room screaming, "My little angel! What have you done to my angel?" when you're still inside the fallen celestial being. Oh, she had fallen. There was no turning back for Lorraine Mischner, fortune cookie heiress. ...
Runner Up
back to top
2004
Winner
Scarves - After my older sister Lona ran away from home, and my father said this was the last straw and she better not show her face around our house again until she was ready to return the jewelry and money she stole, my mother took up knitting. She started with scarves. Apparently scarves take the least amount of planning and concentration, and when you're thirty-eight and you don't know where your fourteen year old daughter is spending her nights and you have decided to learn knitting for the first time, the last thing you want to do is concentrate. And besides, my mother reasoned, no matter how long, misshapen, and contorted a scarf turns out to be, there is always someone, somewhere who can still use it. Inevitably, that someone ended up being me. ...
Runner Up
back to top
|